Fishing in Montauk: The Complete Guide

Studying Time: 9 minutes

Fishing in Montauk is nothing in need of unbelievable. Thrown approach out on the tip of Lengthy Island, surrounded by open ocean, every part right here revolves across the water. The city has the biggest fishing fleet within the state. It was additionally the stage for a number of world report catches. In brief, Montauk is all about man versus the ocean.

On this article, we cowl the highest fish species, strategies, fishing spots, seasons, and extra to be sure you get essentially the most out of your time at “The Finish.” Turn out to be Brody in your very personal battle with Jaws. Solid into bays boiling with fish throughout Montauk’s Striper blitz. In any other case, simply haul in some tasty treats with the household. No matter you’re after, you’ll discover it right here in spades.

Prime Fish Species in Montauk

Montauk is completely positioned for superior angling. Each species migrating out and in of Lengthy Island Sound knocks on its door twice a yr. Heading offshore, you get a 20-mile head begin in comparison with the mainland. Then there are the robust currents and construction that predators like to hunt in. Add that each one collectively and also you get plenty of fish. Listed below are a number of of the native favorites.


The blue water off Montauk is house to a wide range of enormous, toothy terrors. Mako Sharks are the star of the present, identified for his or her unimaginable acrobatics and nearly human-like intelligence. It’s also possible to discover large Blues and Threshers – simply ask the man who caught the world report Blue Shark right here in 2001.

Makos, Threshers, and Blues are the massive three within the Montauk Shark fishing scene, however they’re not alone. It’s also possible to discover Tiger and Hammerhead Sharks within the deepest reaches. You would possibly even see a Nice White. That is Jaws territory, in spite of everything. White Sharks are strictly protected, however even a glimpse of those majestic beasts is one thing you’ll always remember.


In case you suppose Sharks are the one monsters patrolling these seas, suppose once more. Bluefin, Yellowfin, and Albacore Tuna additionally move by on their annual migrations. You’ll be able to even discover Bigeye Tuna out on the canyons, on the sting of the continental shelf. Nothing compares to the sheer energy and dedication of a hooked Bluefin, however all 4 species put up a severe combat.

There’s yet another “Tuna” that folks go loopy for in Montauk – False Albacore. Albies come screaming previous Lengthy Island on the finish of summer season. “Little Tunny” might solely be a fraction of the scale of “true” Tunas, however they put up sufficient combat to be listed with one of the best of them. Specifically, catching Albies on the fly is an expertise each angler ought to strive. 

Striped Bass

Montauk’s Striped Bass fishing is the stuff of legends. Throughout the annual Striper blitz, the shallows get so stuffed with fish that there’s barely room for them to swim. You’ll be able to virtually stroll on the water, it’s that thick with fish. In case you’re struggling to think about what that might seem like, this could offer you an concept.

Sound like enjoyable? It positive is! And in contrast to deep sea monster hunts, it’s one thing that anybody can take pleasure in. Seasoned anglers can wrestle cows to beat their private greatest. Newbies can really feel the joys of casting into the raging foam and reeling of their first Striper. And did we point out that Striped Bass are scrumptious? No marvel they’re one in every of America’s favourite fish.


Montauk is legendary for its large “doormat” Fluke, aka Summer time Flounder. The world report was set right here approach again in 1975 at an eye-popping 22 kilos. Native anglers have been attempting to beat it ever since. Even should you don’t catch a record-breaker, you’re in for some good fights and scrumptious fillets should you go Fluke fishing in Montauk.

However what about all the opposite Flounder species? We’re glad you requested. In addition to the Summer time Flounder, you could find Winter Flounder and Yellowtail Flounder in Montauk. These guys aren’t practically as huge or widespread, however they do tag the Fluke out when the water will get chilly.


In case you’re simply after a little bit enjoyable and a few tasty fish to point out for it, Porgy fishing is for you. Also called Scup, these little critters make for superb desk fare. They’re additionally straightforward for teenagers and learners to catch. All informed, Porgies are the right goal on a household fishing journey.

It gained’t simply be Scup on the tip of your line, thoughts you. Your common journey may also put you on Black Seabass, Tautog (Blackfish), and extra, relying on while you go. You gained’t go hungry after backside fishing round Montauk.

Important Types of Fishing in Montauk

You could possibly write a ebook on the methods and ways for fishing in Montauk. Actually, a number of folks have. As an alternative of spending the following 5 hours going into element about each method and deal with setup, we’ll cowl the professionals and cons of the 2 foremost methods of working these waters: constitution fishing and surf fishing.

On a Boat

There’s a cause why Montauk has the largest constitution fleet in New York. Fishing on a ship actually enables you to get essentially the most of your journey. Actually, it’s the one strategy to goal species like Tuna and Sharks. You’re extra cell, permitting you to comply with the fish. You need to use methods like trolling and drifting that simply aren’t doable from shore. It’s also possible to carry much more gear.

It’s not all clean crusing, although. The seas round Montauk are among the most difficult within the Northeast. Suppose robust currents, hidden shoals, and large waves. It’s greatest to have an skilled native on the helm. Due to this, most individuals be a part of charters or social gathering boats. In case you’re piloting the boat your self, at all times fish with any individual who is aware of the realm.

From Shore

Montauk is the “Surf Fishing Capital of the World.” It’s so simple as that. The city has among the most stunning seashores you can ask for. Simply past the sand, huge boulder fields dot the surf, creating cowl for fish and limitless enjoyable for anglers. Stripers are the star of the surf, however you’ll additionally discover loads of Bluefish and False Albacore should you time your journey proper.

It may be robust to search out house in Montauk throughout excessive season. Seashores are thick with fishermen or bustling with beach-goers. When you discover a spot, your fishing gear will take a beating from the tough seas (rod rental isn’t actually an choice). In case you want repairs or replacements, Paulie’s Sort out ought to have the ability to type you out – it’s a pillar of the native surf fishing scene.

Greatest Fishing Spots Round Montauk

We’ve lined the primary execs and cons of every type of fishing. We’ve gone over what you’ll be able to catch. Now you simply must know the place to do it. Clearly, one of the best honey holes are a closely-guarded secret. The one strategy to discover them is by spending time with native anglers. Within the meantime, listed here are a number of good spots to get you began.

Boat Fishing Spots

  • The Elbow: This traditional Striper fishing spot sits simply off the tip of Montauk Level. The currents might be robust, however the Striped Bass and Bluefish don’t appear to thoughts.
  • The Frisbees: Sitting a few miles off Ditch Plains is without doubt one of the greatest Fluke fishing spots in Montauk. Count on trophy-sized Flatfish in addition to loads of Black Seabass.
  • Butterfish Gap: A traditional Shark and Tuna spot simply 20 miles south of Montauk. The fish don’t get that huge right here, however you’ll be able to take pleasure in a slice of the motion with out the lengthy journey.
  • Fishtails: For monster Tuna, Sharks, and Marlin, head to the canyons. Also called Block Canyon, the Fishtails are a very good 70 miles away. It’s a future, however effectively value it.

Shore Fishing Spots

  • Montauk Lighthouse: The rocks across the lighthouse are a tremendous Striper and Albie spot. Close by Turtle Cove can also be nice should you choose to fish from the seashore.
  • Browns: One other rocky spot simply south of the lighthouse. Park at Camp Hero and take a stroll till you see exercise within the water. You’ll be locked in battle earlier than you realize it.
  • Shagwong Seaside: An incredible Northside Striper spot, particularly when the outgoing tide washes fish near the shore. You want a particular allow to drive right here, although.
  • Ditch Plains: Sand, rocks, parking – what extra may you want? Ditch Plains Seaside itself can get busy, so discover east alongside the shore till you discover some casting house.

When to Go to

Even distant spots can get crowded in excessive season.

Montauk is a extremely seasonal fishery. Most species are solely on the town for a few months on their journey alongside the Atlantic coast. Due to this, you really want to plan out while you’re going to go to. It’s also possible to participate in some superior occasions should you time your journey proper.

Montauk Fishing Seasons

The Montauk deep sea fishing season begins in late June, when the primary huge Bluefin present up. By July, all 4 Tuna species are round, as are Montauk’s notorious Sharks. Bluefin head north in August, however come again for spherical two in September. That is the peak of Montauk’s huge sport chew.

Inshore, issues are fairly comparable. The largest Striper blitzes often occur in September and October, which can also be the one time you’ll be able to goal Scup on a constitution. It’s not all fall enjoyable, although. There’s a brief spring Striper run, and Bluefish and Fluke are on the town all summer season lengthy.

Montauk isn’t utterly useless in winter, both. The chilly months are literally one of the best time to focus on Groundfish like Cod. It’s also possible to catch the tip of the Tautog season in December. Nevertheless, most constitution boats shut up store or head south in the course of winter.

On the lookout for extra in-depth data? Take a look at our full fishing calendar for particulars on what’s scorching every month and when to focus on all of Montauk’s prime fish species.

Montauk Fishing Tournaments

For some folks, the fish themselves don’t put up sufficient of a problem. To others, half the enjoyable of fishing is assembly fascinating, like-minded folks. If that sounds such as you, you’ll be joyful to listen to that there are a number of fishing tournaments held in Montauk annually.

Large sport anglers have two occasions to select from. The oldest is the Montauk Marine Basin Shark Match. It’s been going for 50 years and focuses on catching one enormous Shark per day whereas tagging the remaining to assist with conservation. The Montauk Canyon Problem sees anglers velocity out to the canyons on the hunt for Tuna, Mahi Mahi, Wahoo, and Sharks.

Inshore, you’ve additionally obtained two foremost decisions. Shore-based anglers reel of their greatest Stripers and Bluefish within the Montauk Surf Fishing Traditional. Boaters can be a part of the Montauk Mercury Grand Slam to focus on Fluke, Blufish, Striped Bass, and Seabass. This match has three divisions: leisure, skilled, and social gathering, so everybody can become involved.

Ultimate Ideas

You recognize what you need to catch. You recognize when, the place, and the way you’re going to do it. We gained’t hold you off the water for much longer, we promise. Earlier than you go, there are a few issues value mentioning. Listed below are our ultimate recommendations on fishing in Montauk.

Secure Launch

We suggest that you just solely hold fish that you just’re planning to eat. That is much more essential for species which might be dealing with extinction. Bluefin Tuna and Mako Sharks are each endangered species, whereas Thresher Sharks and Bigeye Tuna are susceptible to extinction. Launch these fish to be sure that your grandkids additionally get the prospect to catch them.

No matter you catch, it’s essential to verify it swims off wholesome. There are a number of easy methods to do that: At all times use circle hooks, keep away from utilizing super-light deal with that exhausts the fish, and hold it within the water always should you can. These are straightforward adjustments that make an enormous distinction to a fish’s probabilities of surviving.

Fishing Licenses

Don’t want a license to fish for saltwater species in New York. Nevertheless, you might must enroll within the Leisure Marine Fishing Registry. That is utterly free and also you solely must do it as soon as per yr. In case you’re fishing on a constitution or social gathering boat, you don’t even want to do that.

Some species, like Tuna and Sharks, require a particular Extremely Migratory Species Allow. Once more, should you’re on a fishing constitution, this might be lined by your captain. Nevertheless, should you’re planning on taking your individual boat out, be certain to use in good time forward of your journey.

Fishing in Montauk: Far From the Final Resort

Montauk has gained some fairly unfair nicknames over time. Some name it “A small ingesting city with a giant fishing downside.” To others, it’s merely “The Final Resort.” Nevertheless, for these within the know, Montauk is an angler’s paradise. From sandy seashores to the deepest reaches of the Atlantic Ocean, the city has some unimaginable angling ready for you. You’ll find it irresistible.

Have you ever ever been fishing in Montauk? The place did you go, and what did you catch? Share your prime fishing suggestions or tear ours aside. Both approach, we’d love to listen to from you!

Leave a Comment