A Complete Guide to Fishing in Long Island

Studying Time: 10 minutes

It’s no shock that the most important island on the US mainland provides unimaginable angling alternatives. However that it could possibly all be explored only a stone’s throw from one of many world’s best metropolises provides one other dimension to fishing in Lengthy Island. Take a brief experience out of New York Metropolis and you might end up a complete world away from the hustle and bustle. Sit back in beautiful seaside cities, on lovely seashores, or out on the water, and solid your line for wealthy rewards!

Wherever you might be on “the island,” as New Yorkers prefer to name it, you’re not removed from sterling fishing motion. The bays and creeks in direction of town are filled with inshore favorites, with bights and sounds throughout, too. And don’t neglect that the Atlantic Ocean can be in your doorstep! From inshore journeys studying the ropes to offshore adventures battling it out with monster fish, all the things is feasible! So let’s dive in and see what Lengthy Island fishing is all about.

What fish can I catch in Lengthy Island?

Earlier than selecting your subsequent fishing vacation spot, you need to know what’s biting the place. Regardless of harsh winters, Lengthy Island is a 365-day-a-year fishery, so there’s all the time one thing able to take your bait while you go to. Whether or not seeking to fill the coolers inshore or for that dream catch offshore, there’s one thing for you. Right here’s our decide of the highest species to focus on in Lengthy Island.


Lengthy Island Fluke fishing is famous. Winter Flounder, Summer season Fluke, and Yellowtail Flounder all inhabit these shallow waters. Sound complicated, learn our information on the distinction between them! As with most creatures right here, Fluke are closely regulated, so that you’ll solely be capable of preserve them between April and September. However that’s loads of time to fill your freezer with fish fillets for the entire yr!

You received’t need to miss out on the season. These scrumptious creatures are seafood favorites all alongside the East Coast, and the entire nation! They’re enjoyable to focus on, as they crawl alongside the muddy bottoms, requiring energy greater than method to hook ‘em aboard. The entire household can goal them – simply ensure to deliver loads of dwell or useless bait, and also you’re positive to get your fill!


Whereas Fluke is a delicacy throughout the US, Seabass is a worldwide desk fare fish. Nonetheless, the East Coast selection is definitely a member of the Grouper household. That simply means extra excellent news! They’re extremely thrilling to focus on and supply up loads of scrumptious meat! These creatures like to feed alongside the bottoms, very similar to Flounder, however promise an actual battle to get off the top of your line as soon as hooked.

Hit any spot the place there’s some construction and, likelihood is, there’ll be a Seabass biting. The season is open from June by the top of the yr, when you may attempt backside fishing with dwell bait to draw their consideration. If you hook one, prepare for an actual combat! When you do get them aboard, ensure to snap an image along with your jet-black fish, earlier than cooking up a scrumptious dinner.


Talking of dinner, probably the most infamous fish dish – Fish and Chips – is often made with one in every of Lengthy Island’s most-coveted creatures. Cod is among the most sought-after creatures within the Atlantic, and it comes shut as much as shore within the north of Lengthy Island. The Lengthy Island and Block Island Sounds are the best areas, so a visit out of Montauk guarantees the best prizes.

Whereas not as enjoyable to catch as Seabass, it’s positively simply as, if no more, rewarding. And the higher information? You may catch it year-round! Effectively, in idea. There’s no seasonality restriction for Cod, nonetheless, you’ll more than likely solely be capable of goal them in winter and early spring. Troll the deeper spots or backside fish the place they’re biting and get your fill of tasty fish fillets!

Striped Bass

For sure, probably the most coveted fish in Lengthy Island, nonetheless, is the Striped Bass. Rockfish, as they’re generally identified right here, develop to unimaginable sizes and promise an actual combat together with loads of scrumptious rewards to take residence. Actually, Striped Bass fishing is so widespread in Lengthy Island that we’ve devoted a complete weblog publish to it.

Throughout the island, you’ll discover these creatures seeking to gobble your bait, so put your line on the market and prepare to do battle! They’re obtainable to take residence from April onwards, so there’s no excuse to overlook out on the motion. Use any method you want – trolling, backside fishing, and even fly fishing can yield nice outcomes!


So sufficient about inshore fishing in Lengthy Island. Now it’s time to show our consideration to deep sea fishing. Tuna fishing within the Atlantic isn’t just a pastime for Lengthy Island anglers, however relatively a supply of satisfaction. And so it ought to be! Montauk was residence to New York State’s document Bluefin Tuna catch again in 1977, weighing in at an unimaginable 1971 kilos! 

Nevertheless it’s not all about Bluefin. Yellowfin Tuna are simply as a lot part of the offshore fishing scene through the summer time months. Likelihood is, if you happen to head offshore through the season, you’ll be concentrating on each prized Tuna species. Not solely do each develop to large sizes, however their meals qualities – nicely, they want no introduction. Prepare for a severe higher physique exercise, as you spend upwards of 10 hours on the water attempting to get your identify within the historical past books!

And Extra!

On prime of the prized species we’ve talked about above, there are lots extra to sink your hooks into. Inshore, Tautog (or Blackfish to the locals) and Scup make for equally-tasty desk fare as Flounder and Seabass, whereas Bluefish and Weakfish are a worthy supporting solid to Stripers. You may as well attempt crabbing a lot of the yr, to arrange no less than a two-course meal.

Head to the deeper waters and the checklist of fish you may goal is sort of infinite. Mahi Mahi typically rub shoulders with Tuna, whereas Kingfish and Amberjack typically come near shore. Wherever you might be, preserve your eye out for Sharks, as Threshers nearshore and Makos offshore are positive to get your adrenaline ranges racing!

The way to Go Fishing in Lengthy Island

So what you need to catch, now it’s about getting the most important bang in your buck. Happily, Lengthy Island actually makes probably the most of its fishing potential. From wade fishing within the creeks, to removing a chosen pier, all the best way as much as massive offshore sportfishing vessels – there’s one thing for every kind of angler right here.

Lengthy Island Surf Fishing

Whereas we all know there’s extra to fishing than simply sitting by the water all day, generally it’s simply what you want. What higher strategy to get away from all of it and concentrate on what’s essential – fishing? Attempt the seashores, grassy flats, creeks, and even some constructions protruding into the water. Wherever you go, all of the inshore favorites are on the menu!

The bays on the north facet of the island make for wonderful shore fishing motion, permitting you to get proper up near the fish. In the meantime, the south shore is the place you’ll discover the most effective shallow creeks. Don’t neglect about Captree State Park and its devoted fishing space, nor Hearth Island with over 30 miles of seashores so that you can solid from.

Lengthy Island Pier Fishing

Any inshore fishing vacation spot price its salt makes probably the most of its environment. Lengthy Island is not any totally different. Wherever you might be on the island, you received’t be removed from a fishing pier to get you out on the water. These constructions get you nearer to the fish, give you an amazing view of your goal species, and offer you that additional little bit of buy when reeling ‘em in. They usually additionally do a job in attracting the fish! Fish from any pier in Lengthy Island, and we’re positive you’ll achieve success.

Captree State Park is once more a hotspot for pier fishing, with no fewer than 4 fishing piers. Lengthy Seashore, nearer to NYC, has its personal pier, whereas Babylon and Hearth Island even have their very own constructions on the south shore. Within the north, head to Cedar Seashore, Stony Brook, or Port Washington and get in on the motion. In the meantime, Shinnecock Canal, Sag Harbor, and Navy Seashore additionally boast piers additional east.

Lengthy Island Social gathering Boat Fishing

If pier fishing is the “achieved factor” in inshore waters, then social gathering boat fishing should give it an in depth run for its cash. A favourite means of fishing all alongside the East Coast’s bays, this manner of fishing has been seized upon by native captains and businessmen, turning massive fishing vessels into social gathering boats for leisure anglers.

The boats are gradual, so that you received’t go additional than the bays, however that’s the place a few of the finest motion takes place! They’re an amazing choice for solo anglers on a finances. Nonetheless, corporations can rent a complete vessel for team-building workout routines, or you may rent them for personal events! Whoever you go together with, you’re in for loads of enjoyable.

Lengthy Island Constitution Fishing

The one factor that may beat fishing on a ship with a load of different folks is fishing on a ship along with your nearest and dearest. Actually, it blows it out of the water – pun supposed! Spend your time exploring a spread of fishing grounds, going after the fish you need. And, in fact, it’s the one strategy to get offshore!

Your skilled captain shall be joyful to offer a serving to hand to newbies, whereas they’ll additionally present the newest gear for many who need to catch ‘em all. Montauk is known all over the world for its fishing charters, whereas Captree and Babylon boast the most important fleets. However you may’t go incorrect from Lengthy Seashore through Huntington and Hearth Island to the ocean. 

Lengthy Island Freshwater Fishing

With a lot on supply in saltwater, you could assume it’s no shock that freshwater fishing on the island is commonly missed. Nonetheless, we’re right here to let you know that’s a mistake. If you happen to’re a freshwater fanatic or simply fancy mixing issues up, Lengthy Island has loads of choices. Fly anglers, particularly, will relish the possibility to flee the crowds and get their fish on…

The island’s lakes and ponds are stocked with all of the nation’s favourite freshwater fish. Largemouth Bass, Trout, Perch, Catfish, Carp, and a complete vary of Panfish are positive to maintain you entertained. There could even be the odd Walleye lurking about! Nassau County round Hampstead boasts a few of the finest spots, whereas Lake Rankonkonen – the most important on the island – is filled with rewards, too.

Lengthy Island Fishing Spots

So we’ve talked concerning the what and the way. Now it’s all the way down to the “the place.” Regardless of if you happen to’re on foot, in search of a pier, or questioning which physique of water to hit, you need to know the place the honey holes are. Right here’s our decide of the most effective locations to go fishing in Lengthy Island.

  • Hearth Island: The 31-mile stretch of seashore speaks for itself. It’s the perfect spot for surf fishing, with entry to the bays, inlets, and Atlantic.
  • Robert Moses State Park: Linking as much as Hearth Island, this can be a prime surf fishing spot for Fluke and Bluefish, in addition to crabbing. There’s a golf course, too, so you may take a break from fishing everytime you need!
  • Shinnecock Bay: Presumably the most effective fishing spots within the Hamptons are alongside this wealthy physique of water. Hit the canal that hyperlinks the north and south shores or head out onto the bay itself. Pier fishing, surf fishing, and charters are all attainable right here.
  • Montauk: We couldn’t discuss the most effective fishing spots in Lengthy Island with out mentioning this city. It’s the gateway to a few of the island’s finest fishing grounds, with the Block Island and Lengthy Island Sounds, together with the Atlantic inside attain.
  • Atlantic Ocean: Talking of the Atlantic, we couldn’t not point out it, both! Chances are you’ll assume we’re dishonest by together with such a big physique of water, however the offshore motion in summer time merely can’t be overwhelmed.
  • Lake Rankonkonen: If you happen to’re in search of freshwater motion, then look no additional than Lengthy Island’s largest lake. Shore fishing, pier fishing, and boat ramps imply you could sort out the lake whichever means you need, as you look to land a prized fish. 


Fishing in Lengthy Island – and, in truth, the entire of New York – is fairly easy. If you happen to’re fishing on a registered boat, you received’t want a license in any respect. Nonetheless, if you happen to’re fishing from shore or aboard your individual vessel, you’ll must register with the Leisure Marine Fishing Registry. Don’t fear although, it’s completely free!

If you happen to’re pondering of hitting the freshwater fishing grounds, you’ll, nonetheless, require a license. Learn how to get yours with our useful information.

In relation to different rules, we’ve already allow you to in on a few of the species’ seasonalities. Nonetheless, most fish are additionally topic to bag and measurement limits – and so they can change relying on the season. Discover out all the things you want to know on the NY DEC web site. 

And You’re Good to Go!

You need to now be all set to go fishing in Lengthy Island. Whether or not on a brief hop from the Massive Apple or spending a complete trip, the island has lots to maintain you entertained. Settle in for some thrilling angling motion and reap the rewards over a scrumptious fish dinner on the finish of the day. We’re positive that, when you come to Lengthy Island as soon as, you’ll come again time and time once more!

Have you ever ever been fishing in Lengthy Island? How was it? Share your experiences with us within the feedback under. 

Leave a Comment